The Punisher has indeed seen multiple interpretations over the years, with Thomas Jane and Jon Bernthal emerging as standout portrayals for many fans. Jane’s performance in the 2004 film captured the gritty essence of the character while also bringing a certain vulnerability to Frank Castle. His rendition laid a foundation for audiences, showcasing a more traditional superhero narrative intertwined with themes of revenge and justice.

On the other hand, Jon Bernthal’s portrayal in the Netflix series takes Frank Castle to darker depths. His gritty, raw performance brings an intensity that resonates deeply with the character's tragic backstory and moral complexities. Bernthal illustrates the psychological toll of Castle's quest for vengeance, allowing viewers to truly understand the pain and determination driving him.

Both actors brought something unique to the role, and their interpretations highlight the multifaceted nature of The Punisher, making their versions memorable for different reasons.